Monkey Island fan vote

[Bloodwych]

First and second about the same. But I'll go with the first, because, er, it came first!

[Sharingan]

The first two are both bloody brilliant, but I voted 1 anyway, because ... er ... it has less disks to swap. Right.

[Thunderhawk]

thanks everyone, Monkey Island 2 LeChucks Revenge was my favorite because it plays on your mind and gives you nightmares, especially when you take Wally’s monicle you can stand for hours and watch him talk to himself and it makes you feel guilty, Monkey Island 2 LeChucks Revenge is so atmospheric you feel like your actually there the attention to detail is fantastic, in woodtick you can go the bloody lip and watch the sea life passing the windows , I also like the green water under the bridge in woodtick

I’m looking forward to the xbox 360 arcade version of the Secret Of Monkey Island, too because it includes the original and the new version with voice acting, there also going to be releasing Monkey Island 2 LeChucks Revenge the original version and the new version on xbox 360 arcade and the other 2 games in the series.

I will be getting them regardless of already having them and playing them since they were original released

Murray, also appears in Monkey Island 4 Escape From Monkey Island, I think its a good game but not as good as the first two.

I like Secret Of Monkey Island Monkey Island 2 LeChucks Revenge is my favorite, The Curse of Monkey Island is good but without Ron Gilbert the story didn’t get continued as good as it could have been, I really liked Escape from Monkey Island.

[J T]

I didn't play MI2 until it had been out a long long time (in fact, I bought it on a CD-ROM budget release, with MI on the same disc, on the virgin 'white label' range).

It seemed to me that MI2 had a more maudlin and sad atmosphere to it. I think I probably enjoyed the original monkey island the most.

I've played the remake (Monkey Island special edition) on the 360 and it is very well done indeed, although I think i preferred the more realisitic character-look to the new cartoon style, some of the faces (Gov Marley) look a bit too goofy. The ability to switch back to classic mode on the fly is super neat; but I did find myself switching to calssic mode and back repeatedly rather often so I could have a look at every location in the style I remembered.

[J T]

Anyone played Tales?

I found it started slowly, and a bit annoyingly, but by the end of the episodes i was thoroughly enjoying it. Well worth checking out.

[Phantom]

As I didn't have a peecee back in the DOS days (only Amiga, so I've played only the first two Monkey Island's), I have to say that I liked most the first one. Not that the second is bad, but the first one I've finished it twice (one in Amiga and one under PSP via ScummVM).

[burns flipper]

I played Tales, that was good. Was a bit tricky inside the manatee. Liked the ending, very clever.